Fortis plans legal steps to recover money from ex-boss Malvinder Singh; loss soars

By Joseph Rai

  • 27 Jun 2018
Fortis plans legal steps to recover money from ex-boss Malvinder Singh; loss soars
Credit: Shah Junaid/VCCircle

Fortis Healthcare Ltd, which is in the midst of a takeover battle, said on Wednesday it will take legal measures against former promoter and chairman Malvinder Singh for alleged fraud as the company revealed a multi-fold jump in losses for the year through March.

The company has submitted an investigation report on the alleged misuse of funds with the Securities and Exchange Board of India and the Serious Fraud Investigation Office, part of the Ministry of Corporate affairs, Fortis said in a stock market disclosure.

The investigation by law firm Luthra & Luthra revealed that there were certain systemic lapses resulting in higher provisions, Fortis said. The company will also appoint an external agency to establish the highest level of governance and internal controls, it added.


Fortis has been battling a barrage of legal matters associated with former promoters Malvinder Singh and his brother Shivinder Singh, whose stake in the hospital chain have fallen below 1%. The brothers allegedly siphoned off at least $78 million from Fortis without any board approval, according to media reports.

Fortis also said that independent director Rohit Bhasin has resigned from the board due to personal commitments. His resignation follows the removal of Brian Tempest from the board, who was one of four directors appointed to the board by the Fortis founders, by the shareholders. Three other directors had quit even before the shareholders’ meeting took place to decide their fates. The board now has has only three directors.

Loss widens


The legal mess surrounding the company has reflected on its financial results, which had been delayed.

The company’s net loss widened to Rs 932 crore for the quarter ended 31 March 2018 from Rs 63.8 crore a year earlier due to continuing business challenges, impairments and provisions. For 2017-18, its net loss stood at Rs 1,009.2 crore as compared with Rs 426.1 crore the year before.

Provisions amounted to Rs 580 crore in the quarter, Fortis said, adding that recovering the amount is doubtful. Impairment losses for the year were around Rs 327 crore.


The company had net debt of Rs 1,404 crore and a net debt-to-equity ratio of 0.26 times as on 31 March 2018. This compares with a net debt of Rs 1,279 crore and a net debt-to-equity ratio of 0.20 times as on 31 March 2017.

Fortis also said that the board of diagnostics unit SRL Ltd, in which it holds a 56.4% stake, is also being reconstituted. Earlier this month, Fortis had scrapped an amalgamation scheme proposed 19 months ago that entailed spinning off SRL into a separate listed company without floating an initial public offering.

Fortis sale


Meanwhile, the company is running a new bidding process for its sale. This has attracted bids from a consortium of Hero Enterprise Investment Office and Burman Family Office, Malaysia’s IHH Healthcare Berhad, KKR-backed Radiant Life Care Pvt. Ltd, and TPG-backed Manipal Health Enterprises Pvt. Ltd.

The four bidders initially had to submit binding bids by 14 June, but Fortis extended the deadline to 28 June.

The grim financials and the legal cases against Fortis could all play out negatively in the valuations the bidders finally quote. Earlier, all of them had outbid each other in the first round of bidding that was eventually declared invalid.


Fortis has been looking for buyers for more than a year. In late March, it agreed to sell its hospital business to TPG-Manipal. But the decision led to an outcry from some minority shareholders on concerns the TPG-Manipal offer undervalued Fortis. This opened the door for other suitors to bid for the company.

Subsequently, Malaysia’s IHH Healthcare, the consortium of Munjal-Burman, China’s Fosun and KKR-backed Radiant Life offered to invest in Fortis. As the bidding war intensified, TPG-Manipal, IHH Healthcare, Munjal-Burman and Radiant Life revised their offers by one or more times.

Finally, on 10 May, the Munjal-Burman consortium was selected as the winner of the takeover battle. However, the decision was likely made against the opinion of some of the board advisers and had not gone down well with a section of the company’s shareholders.

Within days of the winning announcement, TPG-Manipal raised the offer to buy Fortis and later extended its validity period. IHH Healthcare also extended the validity period of its offer.

Fortis decided to initiate a fresh process altogether on May 29 as the winning bid of the consortium of Hero Enterprise Investment Office and the Burman Family Office stood mutually terminated.

Share article on